Category Archives: anime

Genshiken – A Secret Santa Series Review

My favorite annual anime blog tradition has now come back around in the Secret Santa Project that Reverse Thieves has hosted for almost a decade now. It’s a joy to discover a good series that I would have otherwise been passed over and it’s a joy to discover that the recipient of my picks enjoyed something I picked for them.

So far, my track record in receiving good picks has been very good. Will this year continue the string or did I receive a big lump of coal this year?

Continue reading Genshiken – A Secret Santa Series Review


Macross – Series Review

The Macross franchise, like many other long running franchises (Lupin, Gundam, Doctor Who, etc.), can intimidate prospective viewers by their size and by the age of their earliest works. Last year’s Macross Δ appeared to be only loosely tied to it’s earlier works and offered new viewers the chance to sample the franchise. I decided to give the series a go and it turned out to be a pretty decent series. The references and the connections to the larger franchise went over my head, but, there was enough for a viewer like me to enjoy. So, with only a little more of a push, I recently decided to start from the beginning with the original Macross series titled Super Dimensional Fortress Macross or just Macross.

I found Macross to be a fascinating series to watch. Fascinating enough that I felt the need to write this review when it’s been about five years since I last wrote a proper series review post outside of my Secret Santa reviews.


The series starts in the year 2009. The last ten years have been a turbulent time for humanity. In 1999, an alien space battleship crash lands on Earth and this touches off a war that ends with the UN unifying the world into a single world government. At the same time, humanity also works to repair the alien spaceship so it can defend Earth against threats from space. After a decade of work, the Macross is ready to begin it’s role of protecting humanity, but, an accident occurs during it’s launch and humanity is horrified to find itself at war with the Zentradi, a genetically engineered race of giants who only know war and conquest. With millions of ships at their disposal, nothing seems to be able to stop the Zentradi from extinguishing humanity’s hope for continued survival, until, by chance, the people of Earth discover a secret weapon that may hold the key to keeping humanity alive – the singing talent of a teenage girl.

Thoughts and Impressions

I can imagine what a revelation Macross was when it began it’s 36 episode run back in 1982 because, for a lot of the same reasons, it would still be a revelation if it began airing in 2017.

This might be the point that I most want to convey about Macross. I worried I might react to Macross like those kids that were introduced to Harry Potter first and decided that Lord of the Rings was the derivative work that copied off of Harry Potter. In 2017, there is a much greater diversity of stories that get made into anime. Anime about idols are now common and, since Macross was first created, there’s been decades of mecha series and romance series which feature a love triangle. Also in the decades since, the creator of Macross, Shoji Kawamori, went on to create the Aquarion franchise and the AKB0048 series which use some of the same ideas in some of the same ways. So, Macross should have felt like a retread and yet it didn’t.

There are three main reasons for this.

The first reason is the story in Macross explores a very interesting first contact scenario and it’s resulting culture shock. Cultural superiority is normally thought to go in hand with technological superiority. Here, however, each side is innumerably superior to the other in one aspect and profoundly deficient in the other. Humans have their culture and the Zentradi have their technology and a near infinite number of space ships at their disposal. The two seem mismatched until it sinks in how fragile the stunted Zentradi society is once it begins to react to humanity and it’s culture. Over the many millennium that the cloned Zentradi race carried out their war-making they did not deviate from how they were constructed. They were prohibited from having culture, the genders were segregated (the female army/navy protected the bases and the male army/navy did the conquering and invading), they were not allowed to learn skills beyond basic war skills, and only the leaders of the Zentradi were allowed to develop mentally beyond the level of an elementary aged kid.

The second reason is the story in Macross does not turn away from the darker sub-current of it’s characters and ideas, nor, was it afraid to kill off characters. Of course telling who dies is too much of a spoiler as is telling what nontrivial percentage of humanity is killed onscreen, so, let’s pass over discussing that here. With the story focusing on the culture shock of the Zentradi, it’s obvious that the Zentradi have a very rocky road ahead of them, even for the ones who openly wish to embrace the culture they learn from humans. I worried that Macross would forget about this as the romance aspect of the show gained prominence in the latter half of the series, but, Macross never forgot to incorporate the problems the Zentradi had with the sudden appearance of human culture in their society. This unflinching eye did not spare the human cast either. Many of them had warts to their personality which added to the realism of the characters at the expense of finding them easily likable. My favorite example of this is how one of the supporting characters became an abusive drunk before the series ended. (Not because I condone being an abusive drunk, but, because it’s exceedingly rare for an anime to prioritize realistic characters over likable characters.)

The third reason is the story in Macross does not always go in the most likely direction. I’ve mentioned there’s a love triangle in Macross. Having it resolved by the end of the series puts this show into the uncommon, if not rare, category. Further, without spoiling the resolution, Macross goes into even more rarefied company by not picking the couple that I thought was the likely outcome. I can just imagine the meltdown on social media if Macross had been a new series that was released in 2017. There are other examples, like the climatic battle with the Zentradi occurring well before the end of the series, of when the story surprised me by going in directions I didn’t expect; however, I’m trying to keep the spoilers here to a minimum so I’m going to pass over these as well.

Another thing that sets Macross apart is it’s 36 episode count. This gave the show more time then what most modern anime get to develop it’s characters and examine the interesting ideas at the core of it’s story. Yet, it still was not enough time to really touch on every idea that gets brought up during the course of the show. I know this and, nevertheless, I found it hard not to dock the show a bit for not exploring these ideas. For example, at one point in the show, the Macross ends up in deep space with no chance of being resupplied from Earth. This meant there were not an infinite number of pilots at the disposal of the Macross to fly the small defending mech spacecraft, but, in the subsequent skirmishes we see dozens of pilots get killed each time and no one seemed worried that the Macross would run out of pilots. (It would have been nice to see the military decide they needed to start training women to be pilots.) Another example, the main character, Hikaru Ichijou, is a civilian stunt pilot at the start of the show and, after deciding to join the military, he is given command of two rookie pilots after only a few sorties himself. Even born leaders aren’t perfect leaders from day one so I expected to see Hikaru have to grapple with becoming a leader and having the lives of two pilots depend on him. This didn’t happen, he was shown to be instantly the perfect squad leader.

Since we are on the subject of areas where Macross could have been better, I want to bring up the animation. Now before anyone gets angry at me, let me explain. Yes, the show is 35 years old but my issue with the animation is not one of quality. There were several instances where I, as a person watching in 2017, was wowed by the animation. This includes a sequence in the OP that so mesmerized me that I did not skip watching the OP in any of the 36 episodes. Yes, the character designs and such are dated but I quickly got used to them and it was pleasant to not see poorly done CG being shoehorned into the show. No, my problem is there was a great many instances of footage recycling. There was probably never a time in anime’s history when budget and scheduling issues didn’t force some compromises on an anime production. So, I can understand why I might see the same scene of an exploding ship being used in at least five different episodes. Understanding, though, does not lessen the lost sense of immersion one feels when this corner-cutting pulls the viewer out and reminds them they are watching a show.

A search of the Sakugabooru reveals the scene from the OP I was talking about.  I just loved that ending part where the camera followed the mech as it ran down the street. One can tell the mech’s gun has actual weight and heft just by how it’s animated, which is really cool.

And this scene below just took my breath away. I mean that almost literally because I forgot to breathe the first time I saw it. To my eye, this might be one of the best animated scenes in all of anime.

One area that lost none of it’s luster after 35 years was the music. This is especially important since so much of the story relies on the singing talent of Minmay Lynn. I was not surprised to learn that the voice of Minmay, Mari Iijima, went on to have a very successful music career as a singer-songwriter. The songs themselves are largely standard sounding J-Pop songs with lyrics that can feel a bit cheesy. That sounds like a knock against the songs, but, it’s not. Most of the songs where created to fit into the story and a popular idol singer would be singing crowd pleasing J-Pop songs. For instance, her first hit single in the show – “My Boyfriend’s a Pilot” – was first performed on the Macross when morale was low and people needed something to lift their spirits and get them more committed to fighting the Zentradi. It’s starts off with “Kyuun kyuun / Kyuun kyuun” or “Whoosh whoosh / Whoosh whoosh” and goes from there. I never got tired of hearing these songs which is a pretty good determiner of a quality song. The opening song, though not sung by Mari Iijima, was also a treat. It reminded me of the opening to Space Battleship Yamato when the singer sang with great gusto “Macross Macross” at the end of each verse.

Culture Shock

For the most part, I often forgot I was watching a 35 year old anime; however, occasionally I came across something that made me realize the difference between when this first aired and when I watched it. One such item was when Minmay talked to her parents (she’d been living with her aunt and uncle) about becoming an idol. They were not pleased. They feared she’d up becoming a comfort woman. I about fell out of my chair when I heard/read this. Beyond the slap down towards being an idol, I’ve never seen an anime that acknowledges the existence of this deplorable practice of the Japanese from WWII. And I probably won’t see it again, unless it’s an older anime, because it gets easier to forget something like this happened when time begins to take more and more of the victims. Another example was when a female character was shown wishing to be married and being the mother of a baby. I can’t remember the last time I saw a female character being shown to want a baby. (Nor can I remember the last time I saw a male character being shown wanting to get married and becoming a father.) A third instance of being shocked was when Macross showed Hikaru Ichijou getting drunk enough at a bar that the bartender tells him he’d had enough and then showing him driving to the airport and then flying a plane to the next town over and treating this behavior like it was a normal, okay thing to do. I was expecting something like a Chappaquiddick incident to happen.


Macross is the type of show that I can spend 2500+ words talking about and still feel like it I’ve only scratched the surface of the show. I haven’t mentioned the occasional dose of gut busting comedy that will suddenly pop up in Macross. I haven’t mentioned my favorite supporting character, Claudia LaSalle, or her relationship with Roy Focker. And I’m sure there are many other things I should have mentioned that have slipped my mind. What I won’t forget is Macross’s strong focus on the issues surrounding it’s interesting and unique first contact story. Macross wanted the viewer to understand the disruptive power culture can have on another society and it does an exceptional job of doing so. Nor will I forget the love triangle at the heart of the main character’s story. Love triangles are not my favorite feature in romance story lines, but, Macross did a good job showing how it’s love triangle got set-up and does not shy away from showing the resolution. And lastly, I will remember the music; it needed to be good enough to sell the story and it did not disappoint.

I wish I could have liked the main characters, as a group, more than I did; the defects they were given – to make them feel more realistic – also made them not as likable. The supporting cast as a group was a much stronger group of characters. The use of recycled footage dragged an otherwise very solid animation effort down and blunted the impact of the occasional exceptionally well animated scene. There were a few ideas and situations that Macross seemed set to explore only never to do so. These are probably more noticeable (to the level that I’m mentioning them here in the conclusion) because of how well the show handles the rest of the ideas and situations.

And now we’ve come to the problem with just giving a show a numeric score. I hope this review explains why I feel that Macross is simultaneously not quite a perfect show as well as being a historically important title for anime and such a singular experience that I think just about every anime fan should try watching it.

Final Score: 11/12 A+

Ending: 2/3 – Excellent
Production Values: 1/3 – Above Average
Rewatchablity: 1/3 – Above Average

Recommended? – Yes. Those who hate love triangles or dislike overly dark shows should probably steer clear of Macross, but, everyone else should give series a chance.

You Might Also Like: Knights of Sidonia, AKB0048, Puella Magi Madoka Magica, Space Battleship Yamato 2199, Infinite Ryvius, Aquarion Evol

This is the review card for Macross. I’ve given an in-depth explanation of what it all means here (still to be written) . In brief, each category, at the top, is a way I measure the overall quality of the show. The scores range from -1: below average, 0: average, 1: above average, 2: excellent, to 3: exceptional. The bottom section contains specific items that can influence the overall score upwards. A check mark indicates that I felt the show accomplished a noteworthy effort for that item. A straight tally of points earned will only approximate a final score. I consider the score using my grading scale here at The Null Set to be the real score a show gets and only include the MAL score to help compare reviewed titles against the broader number of series I’ve graded over at MyAnimeList.

And let’s end with a funny Macross gif.

The Anime Recap Episode – # 5: October 2017

As the last bits of summer gave way to the falling leaves, October saw the ending of the summer season of anime and the start of the fall season of anime. I intended to be a proper anime blogger this month; I was going to watch as many of the new shows as possible and write first impression posts of them. It’s been a long time since I last tried to watch more than a cherry-picked group of new shows at the start of a new season and I kinda missed that feeling one gets when realizing they’d stumbled upon a terrible new anime series. I was only partially successful, as the almost month long lack of posts can attest to. I did get to watch a large number of the new series – I’m currently watching 22 – but, the time to write about these series dried up this month as I discovered that rereading the first two books of Brandon Sanderson’s Stormlight Archive was as engrossing as the first time I read them. I thought knowing what happens would have allowed this second time through to be a more relaxed reading experience but I was wrong. There were a long string of days that I lost 1 – 2 hours of sleep a night because I couldn’t stop turning the pages. Oh well, maybe next time.

So, this is my first chance to talk about the new season of anime and I have a lot of ground to cover.

Continue reading The Anime Recap Episode – # 5: October 2017

Top 6 Anime of Summer 2017

One of these times a seemingly weak anime season will actually be as bad as it looked going in. I thought the streak might end with the Summer 2017 season; however, once again, I missed several quality series in my initial estimation and this season turned out to be a pretty decent one. It was far from being one of the best but it also was far from being the worst. Of the fifteen series that I watched this season, six were good enough to warrant inclusion on a best of season list. How did your favorites fair? Read on to find out.

Continue reading Top 6 Anime of Summer 2017

The Anime Recap Episode – # 4: September 2017

September’s fading summer warmth is one my favorite times of the year. The cool nights are prime sleeping weather and the days are still warm enough to keep wearing shorts and t-shirts. It is also, incidentally, a good time to give my sinuses a break from all the stuff that the AC or heater like to kick up. This month also marks the last chance for the currently airing anime to grab our attention and hopefully stave off decent into the pit of oblivion that more than 90% percent of the anime will fall into – forgotten – as soon as the new season of anime starts up in October.

Continue reading The Anime Recap Episode – # 4: September 2017

Best in Anime of Summer 2017

Every time I think an upcoming season of anime looks terrible there turns out to be more than a couple of surprise hits that save the season. The Summer 2017 season was no different. It wasn’t a perfect season by any measure. Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul finished well below expectations and the storytelling of Re:Creators never was able to match it’s inventive setting, to name two disappointments. Who knew, on the other hand, that a show with a name like Princess Principal was going to be so good or that Nana Maru San Batsu, a show about high school quiz bowl, would so quietly become a title I looked forward to watching week after week. This season was also the first time in about two years that I was able to watch every currently airing anime that I wanted to as it aired.

To celebrate, I’m going to do a pair of season in review posts. The first will feature my picks for the season’s best in a number of categories like Best Characters, Best OP/ED, and Best Animation. The second post will feature a countdown of the top shows of the season and will be published once all the possible placing shows have finished airing for the season and I’ve had time to write it.

Now onto the awards.

Continue reading Best in Anime of Summer 2017