Top Picks – Spring 2012 Anime, Part 1

from Space Brothers

In the past I would lament, during a weak anime season, about the inability  to blog about anime when the anime would only inspire lukewarm apathy. This spring season of anime has taught me another way to lament; when a season is as strong as this one and spreads this strength out over the week as well as this season has then it becomes near impossible to find the time to write anything because there is always good anime waiting to be watched – tempting one to put down the pen. And, when it’s a question of watching anime or writing about anime, the answer is pretty clear; so, we’ve reached the start of the next anime season and I now look to rectify some of my silence about the springseason before our collective amnesia sets in too much.

For these awards slash review I wanted to alter my standard format a bit to simplify – condense – clarify – better articulate how these anime series stacked up against each other and better convince potential viewers of the worth of watching these series. But before we get there I need to set the field with all the series I watched this season. If I do not list a show then I have not seen it yet and it will not appear. Also, as great as the new Avatar series was, it falls outside the scope of these awards because it is not anime.

Carry-over shows watched this season (3): Hunter x Hunter, Aquarion Evol, Bodacious Space Pirates

New shows watched this season (19): Eureka Seven AO, Sakamichi no Apollon, Dusk Maiden x Amnesia, Upotte, Polar Bear Café, Hyouka, Mysterious Girlfriend X, Accel World, Uchuu Kyoudai (Space Brothers), Kore wa Zombie Desu ka – Of the Dead, Sankarea, Jormungand, Lupin the Third: Mine Fujiko to Iu Onna, Medaka Box, Tsuritama, Natsuiro Kiseki, AKB0048, Fate/Zero S.2, Phi Brain S.2

Shows that got dropped (2): Acchi Kocchi, Sengoku Collection

The first section of awards focuses on the characters in the various anime series.

Character Awards

Best Male Main Character: Mutta from Space Brothers
Runner-up: Jonah from Jormungand

Best Female Main Character: Koko from Jormungand
Runner-up: Marika from Bodacious Space Pirates

Best Supporting Character: Weaver and Rider from Fate/Zero
Runner-up: Lupin from Lupin the Third: Mine Fujiko

Best Screen grabber: Wishing Rock from Natsuiro Kiseki
Runner-up: Hisoka from Hunter x Hunter

Best Cast of Characters: Aquarion Evol
Runner-up: Space Brothers

Best Couple: Urabe and Tsubaki from Mysterious Girlfriend X
Runner-up: Andy and Mix from Aquarion Evol

Best Character Development: Mysterious Girlfriend X
Runner-up: Tsuritama

Best Villain: Mykage from Aquarion Evol
Runner-up: DES from AKB0048

It is possible to create an excellent anime series without creating minimally decent characters but it’s very difficult. On the flip side, an anime that creates a cast of compelling characters is assured of being at least watchable. The importance of characters is why I like to start my reflection were I do.

Having an anime win or nearly win a character award is often a good measure of which anime series focused on it’s characters but not always. Both winners, Wishing Rock (Best Screen grabber) and Weaver and Rider (Best Supporting Characters), were the sole standouts in a cast of barely proficients in their respective shows and were largely the only reason to watch either anime. Not to take anything away from either. The Wishing Rock is also known as Troll Rock for it’s mischievous interpretations of the main character’s wishes. Weaver and Rider stuck out in Fate/Zero, much like a steroid-binging Barry Bonds would while playing on a little league baseball team.

Other times there is an uneven treatment of characters as Jormungand displayed; Koko (Best Female Main Character) and Jonah (Runner-up Best Male Main Character) had plenty of space and screen time to become great characters but the rest of the cast were forgettable and just there to fill space. Both characters are emotionally scarred individuals that grasp whatever pieces of normal humanity they can hold onto while being the best gun dealers in the world.

from Mysterious Girlfriend X

And sometimes the anime is as character-focused as the awards suggest. Space Brothers, Aquarion Evol, and Mysterious Girlfriend X all make multiple appearances because to this focus. Mutta (Best Male Main Character) is a middle-aged man belatingly striving to attain his childhood dream and leads a varied, interesting cast in Space Brothers (Runner-up Best Cast of Characters). Aquarion Evol suffered a bit from a pair of bland main characters but made that up with a great villain – Mykage (Best Villain), and a romantic relationship full of twists by supporting characters Andy and Mix (Runner-up Best Couple) and a large ensemble cast covering two different planets to earn the award Best Cast of Characters. Mysterious Girlfriend X (Best Couple) features a male and female main character that be themselves are good but they only become great when they decide to become each other’s first relationship and they suddenly have a flood of emotions, desires, and actions to bumble through and master. How this well-used story is carried out is what earns Mysterious Girlfriend X (MGX) the Best Character Development Award.

Initially, I’d planned on condensing the number of posts for the seasonal awards down but, in the end, I had to be  contented with making each one shorter.

Top Picks – Spring 2012 Anime, Part 1: Character Awards – currently here
Top Picks – Spring 2012 Anime, Part 2: Content Awards
Top Picks – Spring 2012 Anime, Part 3: Creation Awards
The Top 12 Anime of the Spring 2012 Season – #12 to #7
The Top 12 Anime of the Spring 2012 Season – #6 to #1


3 thoughts on “Top Picks – Spring 2012 Anime, Part 1”

  1. Why would you preclude Avatar in this list simply because it’s not anime? It seems a bit pedantic to not write about something you loved watching. After all, this is your blog: you can do anything you want with it, right? (Which also includes not putting Avatar in these lists, but…)

    I’d like to hear your thoughts on why you think Marika was a runner-up for best female main character too (then again, there weren’t many female mains this season anyways, so…)

    P.S. iirc it’s Waver, not Weaver, but I could be wrong.


  2. @Mushyrulez: Thanks for the comment.

    I specifically mentioned excluding Avatar because it slightly bothers me (in the – there’s dumb people on the internet way – which means it’s not normally worth mentioning it but I sometimes feel the need to do so anyways) that some people can’t seem to grasp the basic definition of what anime is and what’s not anime.

    I do plan on writing a post about the new Avatar series, someday 🙂 .

    You half answered your own question about Marika, there wasn’t a ton of quality female main characters. If the series had been better then Fujiko from the Lupin series probably would have earned either the top or runner-up spot.

    You are apparently correct, I don’t know why I thought it was Weaver.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s