Eden of the East – Impressions and Plot Conjectures

spring19001

Continuing with my spring 2009 anime impression posts is the latest work by the director of Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex and Seirei no Morbito, Kenji Kamiyama – East of Eden. As an original work, it’s impossible to accurately gauge the quality of East of Eden before it aired but from the previews, it looked very promising. So the 64,000 dollar question is will this show buck the trend of mediocrity this season (as a whole) has shown or will it be just be another underwhelming work?

Rating: episode 1 – 11/12A+
Rating: episode 2 – 11/12A+
Anticipation Level: very high

Story

In an event known later as “Careless Monday”, the country of Japan was attacked with 10 missiles. There was a fair amount of property damage but the odd thing about this attack was that apparently no one was killed in these attacks. After this November 2010 attack, the country was on edge but when nothing else happened, the citizens quickly went back to their normal lives and this is where the series starts. Saki is in her last year of college and, in February 2011, has traveled to America with some of her friends to see the sights. She decides to visit the White House but the local cops don’t like it when she tries to throw a coin into the White House fountain. She’s saved from trouble by a fellow Japanese citizen, Akira, who does something a little more threatening – walking around naked with a handgun and a cell phone. His memory has been wiped so he doesn’t know why he’s there but he’s still able to evade capture. He will later learn that the cell phone has been charged with 10 billon yen ($100 million dollars) and by clicking a button on it, he’s connected to a woman named Juiz. Juiz tells Akira that – per his request – she was the one that pointed him to a memory wipe service that is responsible for his amnesia. Juiz also tells Akira that he has a duty to spend the money that’s on the phone.

spring28140

Impressions

Wow, count me as impressed.

Much like Studio Bones’ anime Xam’d: Lost Memories from half a year ago, this showhas a feeling of being of the highest quality from the moment it started. Also like Xam’d, I can’t quite place my finger on why I get the absolutely firm feeling that East of Eden will turn out to be great. It’s not the gorgeous animation that makes me think this, though it definitely doesn’t hurt. Production I.G.’s other spring work, Sengoku Basara, is just as good, if not better, in the animation department but I get a totally different feeling from that show – it being entertaining and fun but not that it’s great.

Nor is it the characters that make me think this could be a great anime (in the sense of it being stately or sublime). Saki, the female protagonist, is a very normal and plain young woman; the type of person that never has anything interesting happen to them. She’s a very sympathetic character because she is so normal and she’s already one of my favorite characters of the season but people like Saki aren’t supposed to lead interesting lives. By the end of episode 2 the story around Akira, the male protagonist, is very intriguing but at the start of episode 1, he’s just a guy that appears in front of the White House, wearing no clothes and carrying a cell phone and a gun. More like a fugitive from a mental hospital and not someone connected to a very mysterious – and rich – group.

Maybe the slightly near-future setting outside of either high school or college along with the notion that the show has a well thought-out plot has helped make the show feel like it is a great anime in the making. But whatever the exact reason, I feel like I could guarantee that this’ll be a great and memorable anime.

Two episodes in and this East of Eden pretty much has everything needed to make it one of the top shows of the season. I already mentioned the great animation, likable characters, and the plot that feels like it’s been well thought-out. Also in the show’s favor is the mystery surrounding the story of this show. Who exactly is Akira and the people behind the phones? What are the aims of this shadowy group? Why did Akira have most of his memory wiped? And why was the eleventh missile attack the only one to kill people? These are all very good questions and the desire to find out the answers is just another why to keep the viewers interested in the show. I really can’t wait to see how the show unfolds.

And finally, other random reasons to like this show: they actually got native English speakers to play the bit characters in episode 1 while the show was in America. I wish this was done more in anime and over here as well. Also the opening song/animation is really cool.

spring09427

Plot Conjectures

Watching these two episodes gave me a lot to think about. When a show has an interesting plot and a mystery, I often like to take guesses as to how the show will progress. Since this is an original work, no one knows how this show will end and I can’t look silly by guessing things that a glance at the wiki article would answer.

The most important piece of the show’s puzzle, I feel, revolves around a saying that’s appeared in the show: Noblesse oblige. It’s a French saying literally meaning “nobility obligates”. As a saying it’s been around a long time, a version of this saying appears in the New Testament of the Bible for instance, but most people are probably familiar with a very recent version of the saying, “with great power comes great responsibility”.

Andrew Carnegie, in an 1889 essay known as the ‘Gospel of Wealth’, set out that the new wealthy of the Industrial Revolution had a responsibility to circulate their wealth back into society for the betterment of society but this philanthropy had to be prudently done with the idea to create opportunities for the impoverished to improve their state permanently. This is why Carnegie spent a large chunk of his fortune on building libraries. Known as “Carnegie libraries”, these libraries formed by backbone of the library system not only in America but in many other countries. (For example, even a hundred years later 37 of the 49 libraries in New York City are Carnegie libraries.)

I mention this because I think whoever is behind the phones charged with the 100 billion yen want the 12 recipients to use the money to better society along the lines of what Andrew Carnegie wrote. I think this because the police officer who’s also IV, sneers at Akira’s use of the money to buy gum, pondering out loud how is this supposed to help society. Also because Juiz tells Akira to continue to be a messiah after taking his request for leaving the airport quickly.

spring15306

I think the fact that there’s 12 phones and thusly 12 people charged with this mission is a clue to who’s behind the missile strikes and the phones. Twelve is a highly symbolic number in Judiasm and Christianity, among other religions. If Jesus was a king then it’s probably realistic to think of the 12 apostles as the princes which would tie into how Saki was saying that Akira was a prince at the beginning of episode 1. As well as make all the text in the opening make a little more sense. So, I think there’s a good chance that a religious cult based in Japan either outside or inside the Japanese government is behind the happenings.

The next question might be why would you give 12 people the ability to possibly better Japanese society. I think this goes back to a conversation in episode 1 where Saki mentions how she thinks Japan has the mindset that they can’t help themselves but need America to do so. Thus her wish when she tried to throw the coin in the White House fountain was for something to happen that would change this mindset and maybe she got her wish.

I have a couple other unconnected thoughts as well. I think if you’re one of the 12 people that are supposed to have a phone then you’re safe from the other 11 people. This makes sense from the standpoint of a group trying to accomplish a mission with these 12 phones and trying to remove the temptation of killing one of the original 12 to get even more money. I think this is why the cop is insistent in figuring out if Akira is the real number 9 and not someone who picked up the phone. If he was a fake, then the cop could have requested the death of Akira and taken the phone.

I noticed in the beginning animation that it shows all 12 badges at one point but then number 4 (the cop we see in episode 2), 5,and 10 disappear. I think this either means that these 3 people will die during the course of the show or maybe these will be people that have spent all their money. The less bloody alternative came to me after noticing that number 4 was down to a measly 7,034 yen left on this balance (about seventy bucks). Though, maybe once you’ve spent your money, you no longer are safe from the other 11.

spring12538

And the last thought I have is that I think Akira purposely wants to stay together with Saki. Watching episode 1, to me it looks like he choose the moment where Saki is in front of the White House as the one to lose his memories and that’s what the weird static sound coming from Akira’s phone was. I also noted that his expression seems to change from one of anger to amusement after hearing that static. Whatever made him want to lose his memories probably also made him angry and by forgetting whatever this was, he’s become a happier person. What also makes me think this is that Akira picks his passport (from several that he owns) that has a birthday most closely matching Saki’s birthday. Also, he probably didn’t need her help finding where his house was located since that phone most likely has a system in place to do so (and he was eavesdropping on Saki while she was in the bathroom).

That’s about all I have to say right now about East of Eden. I’d love to hear what you guys think about my plot conjectures (either positive or negative) as well as your own ideas about the plot behind this show. If the show continues to interest me at this level, you’ll probably see many more posts about this show. I’m particularly interested to see how 9/11 and terrorism plays into this show after these items where introduced.

spring27846

spring30699

spring23034

About these ads

10 thoughts on “Eden of the East – Impressions and Plot Conjectures”

  1. Nice detailed review steel………out of your three plot conjectures the last one got me thinking the most…….it is possible that akira somehow knew saki before his brainwash………..maybe he was trying to forget about her so she wouldnt be dragged into the whole terrorism thing………..but maybe the bond is so strong that he cant stay away from her despite having no memories…….i know that sounds silly because it seems like saki had never seen akira prior to their meeting in DC but its possible for it to be a one sided type thing where he watched over her somehow…..

    anyway that’s just my imagination getting the better of me since that’s highly improbable

    but here is another though…….maybe the group with the phones is not an anti terrorist group or a group trying to carry out deeds for the greater good but a group of terrorists themselves……..if that was the case maybe akira erased his memories to forget some terrible act that he himself might have committed

    those were just some of my thoughts on the show so far…….in any case i look forward to your future posts on this show

    Like

  2. Nice plot conjecture, quite possibly the most well-thought out I have read so far. Part of what you says makes sense especially the part on Noblesse oblige and the responsibility to circulate their wealth back into society for the betterment of society.

    However based on what Akira was spending (before his memory was wipped), he seems to have initiate some program to do just that by spending money to house and feed 20,000 for 2 weeks. Maybe those were the naked people in the photo in his apartment in Washington?

    Also, it possible that he may have initiated his own memory wipe since it was charged to his phone.

    I agree with JayyG that it is possible that one of the 12 could be behind the missile attack on Japan. Careless Monday was carefully planned to ensure no casualty. That cannot be a coincidence. I think its a given that Akira is somehow connected to Careless Monday.

    The possibility of Akira knowing Saki is intriguing but unless he was stalking her or something, it would not explain why he seems to be a stranger to her. I think it was just a coincidence that she was there. But it sure as hell does not explain why he would choose to hold a gun naked in front of the White House. The only reason why anyone would want to do that is to be caught on purpose. So it possible that Saki’s appearance may have thrown the entire plot into chaos.

    Also Kondo was down to his last million yen (after killing the 3 people)

    Of cos while all these mystery and sinister going-ons is interesting, the reason why this show rox is the chemistry between Akira and Saki. Saki is without doubt the most charming female character this season. The way she looked at herself in the toilet and wondered if she has smiled more is refreshing honest for a female anime character. I love it!

    Most anime struggled to even have a decent conversation between the characters in the entire series. Ep 2 has 3 – count them – 3 engaging and disquieting intimate conversation between the 2 of them. This is good writing!

    Without a doubt, the best series of the season – IMHO.

    Like

  3. Thanks for the well thought out comments.

    @JayyG: You mentioning the possibility of Akira knowing Saki even after a memory wipe made me think of something. That sounds like the movie Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. And in episode 2 where the 11th missile kills everyone on the plane but two reminds me of the movie Unbreakable. I wonder if there’s some connection to how Akira appears to have kept his movie knowledge and some of the possible plot points of this series.

    The 12 phone people could be terrorists themselves but they could still be acting with the idea of improving society – the terrorist groups we see on tv today all think they’re doing the right thing to help society.

    I’d really like to see what it was that made Akira wipe his memory. He seems like such a carefree guy now that I can’t imagine him doing something terrible but maybe that was the point of the memory wipe in the first place.

    @Paul: I was wondering what else Akira had spent money on. That could be what those pictures were and maybe that’s why in episode 1, the guy talking over the phone to Juiz said that Akira was an odd guy. Maybe he’s too much of idealist according to that guy.

    Without checking ep.2, I remember seeing that Kondo had over a million yen but then I was positive I saw his balance go down to 7043 yen after the shooting.

    There is definitely good chemistry between Akira and Saki, which is helped by good writing. Watching this show makes it harder to wade through all the mediocre shows of the season.

    Unless this show fumbles in the coming episodes, I’m almost positive that East of Eden will be my number 1 spring anime.

    Like

  4. According to the folks over at Animesuki, this was what Akira spend before his memory wipe.

    [2011/2/12 2:01] Download of a brainwash program: 900 yen

    [2010/12/11 6:00] Cinema film: 80,000,000 yen

    [2010/12/10 22:30] 20,000 meal delivery for two weeks of (convenience-store) lunch: 136,000,000 yen

    [2010/12/10 9:24] Purchase of an urban management shopping mall: 91,000,000 yen.

    As for Kondo, he was down to 1,506,380 yen after killing the 3 people. I did a screen capture and posted it on another forum. http://sgcafe.com/showpost.php?p=5418145&postcount=74

    According to information provided on the official site, there is a ‘Supporter’ amongst the 12. Each of the 12 were given 10 billion yen to spend “to guide the country (Japan) towards betterment’. So if they do not use the money properly, they will be killed by the ‘Supporter’. I was wondering if Akira could be the Supporter but that would be too easy.

    The synopsis for Ep 3 is also out and we will see a show down between IV and IX. Can’t wait!

    Like

  5. steelhound, you are right about Kondo’s credit balance after he killed those 3 people. It is down to 7000+ yen (7034 yen to be precise)

    I found the transalation for his transactions on another site.

    2/14/11: Killing these three dudes in front of me (1,499,346 Yen)
    - 2/13/11: Entertainment (300,000 Yen)
    - 2/13/11: Electronic scoreboard manipulation (10,000 Yen)
    - 2/13/11: Tokyo Racecourse – Race #7 – Making a lot of trio bets (81,600 Yen)

    Also, his debt was 20 million yen and not 2 million yen.

    Like

  6. @Paul: Thanks for the translation and the info. So Akira spent alot of money on movies the day after he spent a bunch of money feeding people. I wonder what that means and why the long period of not spending money.

    I think it’s funny that it only cost 9 dollars to do a memory wipe on yourself.

    ___
    Something I forgot to bring up in the was Akira and Saki met on Valentine’s Day. I wonder if Akira planned to meet someone that day to become their “prince” and if so, maybe he did somehow know Saki before his mind wipe or he was just randomly trying to find a fellow Japanese citizen in Washington DC.

    Like

  7. well i watched ep 4…………..like paul said if u run out of money the supporter comes and gets u……also it seems like akira really was a dangerous guy it is not clear whether it was really him or not but it appears he might have been the cause of some 20000 NEETS dying

    Like

  8. Yes, very thoughtful and insightful. Which got me to do some thinking about how many hints they dropped in the opening song.

    One interesting thing is the scene where all the numbers appear, this is what happens:

    Four makes contact with Nine and then vanishes
    Two contacts Nine
    One makes contact with Ten
    Twelve makes contact with Three
    One makes contact with every remaining number except Twelve
    Five vanishes
    Ten vanishes

    And as for Saki and Akira…

    My Predictions
    *********************
    1)One is the man in the car in the 1st episode.
    2) Nine (Akira) attempts to kill Saki in the 1st episode but when One drives away, he had preplanned to have his memory erased in order to escape with Saki. I believe he had observed Saki beforehand and knew that if he got naked, Saki would give him her jacket and he knew she had her passport and wallet in there. He intended to fly back to Japan with her all along.
    3) Above, at one point it appears that One contacts all of the Numbers except Twelve… I think this is because he thinks Twelve is dead
    4) I think Saki is Twelve, that is why Akira had to pretend to kill her. To protect her from One and also to establish she is no longer in the game.
    5) Yes, I think Saki and Akira were both players in this game from the very start and that Saki had her memory erased for some reason.

    I know it’s a bit farfetched but I can’t really find another explaination as to why Akira wanted to pretend to shoot Saki… And also, with the above, three made contact with twelve but after that remained just observant. Ten made contact with One twice and died. One seems to have the most power and appears to be dangerous and clearly is not complacent.

    I think the game is really a power struggle for someone to be crowned King of Eden and to see who will win, those with noble intentions or those with bad intentions. Maybe the winner becomes the next Mr. Outside and another game begins…

    Like

  9. The show had mystery and an interesting setup, but I disliked the reveal and exposition at the end. That and the fact that most of the anime did not interest me much, meant Eden of the East got a 3.5. Same score I gave to Summer Wars.

    On this point, you and I diverge greatly, Steel.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s